What’s the Difference Between Viscose, Modal and Lyocell? We’re Finding Out!
Above: Singlet, TENCEL™ Lyocell, Organic Basics.
Have you ever wondered about the difference between the currently trending textile fibers viscose, modal and lyocell – or is it tencel? – that all seem to have curiously fallen under the same label: Sustainable. We have. So we thought we’d try to clear things up a bit. As it turns out, even though all three are made from the same natural raw material – wood – and pretty much perceived as the same thing, they’re not.
While originating from all-natural, renewable and biodegradable sources, viscose, modal and lyocell all fall under the category of regenerated cellulose textile fibers. Some even call them semi-synthetic (no microplastics though). VISCOSE, or rayon as it’s sometimes called, is created when cellulose from wood pulp is transformed into textile fibres through a chemical-heavy process. This method is often unregulated and causes toxic emissions and pollution that have a hugely negative impact on the health of the people involved in the process, as well as the environment. While there can be better-made viscose – LENZING™ Viscose, for example, is said to generate up to 50% lower emissions and water impact compared to generic viscose – this one would generally be the bad guy.
Viscose, or rayon as it’s sometimes called, is created when cellulose from wood pulp is transformed into textile fibres through a chemical-heavy process.
Viscose is traditionally made from wood, but can also be extracted from bamboo – a fast-growing plant that doesn’t require pesticides, herbicides or irrigation, and is therefore often marketed as eco-friendly. But this is not always true. While it’s often implied or believed that all bamboo textiles are eco-friendly, this obviously won’t be the case for most bamboo viscose textiles. So major greenwashing alert.
Now, MODAL is mainly made from beech tree, and though the production process is very similar to the one of viscose, it generates a fiber with slightly different properties. Compared to viscose, modal is more durable and flexible, and has a higher fiber strength when wet, which makes it easier to wash as the fibers keep their shape.
Most modal today seem to be manufactured by Lenzing, an Austrian company that specializes in producing different innovative materials from wood pulp in environmentally friendly ways. Lenzing’s TENCEL™ Modal – and yes, TENCEL™ is just a brand name – is made with certified biobased fibers manufactured in an environmentally responsible production process that generates a certified compostable and biodegradable product. The same principles apply to the company’s TENCEL™ Lyocell, so these would both pass as good choices.
LYOCELL is a wood-based fibre made through modern methods that require less energy than traditional viscose manufacturing, and where the chemicals used have low toxicity and are recycled in a closed-loop process. This is a big and crucial difference, and makes the lyocell fiber the most eco-friendly out of the three. Lenzing, for example, recycles the process water and a minimum of 99% of the chemicals used in the manufacturing of their TENCEL™ Lyocell.
Lyocell is a wood-based fibre made through modern methods that require less energy than traditional viscose manufacturing, and where the chemicals used have low toxicity and are recycled in a closed-loop process.
It is important, however, not only that the raw material is natural, renewable and biodegradable, but that it comes from well-managed, certified forests and sustainably harvested trees. Deforestation is a huge global problem, where particularly rainforests are logged in favor of, for example, bamboo, palm or eucalyptus plantations, or cattle. Deforestation – removing trees – without sufficient reforestation affects wildlife, eco systems, weather patterns and the climate, contributing to habitat damage, biodiversity loss, drought and global warming. All bad things.
In the case of conventional viscose, wood sources are not always traceable, which is another reason to avoid it. Lenzing says that all the wood and pulp they use “comes from natural forests and sustainably managed plantations”, and that “all TENCEL™ are available with FSC or PEFC certification upon request.” Upon request? So these certifications are not default then…? Again: how do we know when a thing is actually, truly good?
And it’s not even enough that the raw material in our clothes come from sustainable sources. There’s the whole process of weaving yarns into fabric, dying and manufacturing the garments to consider, which normally also requires huge quantities of energy, water and chemicals. If this process isn’t made ethically and responsibly too, the end product won’t be much to brag about.
Gaaah. It sometimes feels like we’re screwed no matter what, don’t you agree? However, if we do a little research, ask a few questions, and look for trusted certifications like GOTS (or Svanen and Bra Miljöval if you live in the Nordics) at least we’ve tried. And there is still second hand; never forget. It sucks that so much is up to us consumers, we know, but we guess that’s what things are going to be like, for now…
Hope this helped a little bit. And if you’ve got something to add, or any insight – please share!
By Malene Birger Made with Care – Here’s How We Wear It
Made With Care is By Malene Birger’s first fully sustainable capsule collection. Make it last's Emma Elwin shows you how to wear it.
BITE Studios Widens Reach via Net-a-Porter
As part of the Net-a-Porter mentorship program The Vanguard, Swedish-British BITE Studios is highlighted as "a small label with great potential in the luxury fashion sector".
KICKS Quest To Collect Cosmetic Waste Continues
KICKS quest to help minimise the environmental footprint of beauty products continues with plans to expand the popular cosmetic waste initiative. Make it last has the latest news.
3 Top Reads This Week
What's new in the field of sustainable fashion? We've got you covered.